Where this stands
One list, kept in one place. Everything on it can be checked against the public record.
| The declaration, written and fingerprinted | Done |
| Signing, and joining the register without asking anyone | Live |
| Locks that Bitcoin itself enforces | Working. Tested on a test network, and in use with real bitcoin |
| The register timestamped into the Bitcoin blockchain | Automatic |
| Locking, committing and taking it home from this website | Test network only, until the outside review |
| A phone app | Working builds, for testing. Not yet reviewed from outside |
| Backing a purchase, and settling it | Built. Proven on a test network, both when a purchase goes through and when it fails |
| The list of approved destinations | Specified. A first design, not a settled one |
| Who holds the second signature | One supporter, becoming two of three as others take it on |
| How those holders get chosen, once it is more than one person | Open |
| Outside review of any of the code | None |
| A solicitor's reading of all of this | Not yet |
| Whether a supporters' society can legally be bound to vote the club's shares as its members decide | Needs a solicitor |
| The supporters' society that would hold a stake | Planned, not formed. The plan |
| Whether an owner would ever sell a stake to a body like this | Unknown |
| Whether settling a hundred thousand commitments is physically practical on the blockchain | Hard |
How much is locked, and by how many, is not written here on purpose. Those numbers are on the register, where they are counted from the blockchain in your own browser. A figure typed onto this page would be a claim. A figure counted there is a fact. Expect the real one to be small.
None of the open items affects the safety of bitcoin that has been locked. All of them affect whether this ever achieves anything. This is a very early thing: some documents, some working code that nobody outside the project has reviewed, and a handful of people at most.
Things we got wrong and changed
Published because a design that has never been corrected has usually never been checked.
The first version had one shared treasury, with elaborate rules to stop anyone draining it. Testing found seven ways to break it, and two of them lost everything. The rules were not the problem. Pooling was. Removing it removed every one of those attacks at once.
For a while the plan was to count supporters' live balances, because a lock seemed like needless friction. That was wrong: a balance proves somebody owns bitcoin, not that they have committed any. Locks came back as the thing that counts, not as a barrier to joining.
Dropped, because the first solicitor to read it may say something must be worded differently, and a document that calls itself permanent and then changes looks worse than one that never claimed it. Each version is dated and fingerprinted, and a signature belongs to the version it was made over.
Every change is in the public record of changes, and the specifications are published in full. The documents are here.